HUNDREDS of “disgusting” NHS workers have snooped through medical records belonging to the Nottingham stabbing victims in a shocking betrayal of trust.
, whose son Barnaby, 19, was murdered alongside fellow student in 2023, says the snooping is “just the tip of the iceberg”.


They were stabbed to death by paranoid schizophrenic – but have also been let down at every single level by the authorities supposed to protect them.
into confidential A&E notes made hours after they died, provoking widespread public outrage.
Nottingham University Hospitals Trust (NUH) launched a probe and has sacked 15 staff members so far.
But Emma has demanded a full sweep of who , telling The Sun that workers “everywhere you could imagine” looked at the files in what she believes is a sick bid to satisfy their morbid curiosity.
She says that people have even looked at her own medical records, as well as those belonging to Barnaby’s dad. They have no idea who these have been shared with.
The sweep is still ongoing, but so far they have found over 200 instances of records being breached and 15 people have been sacked for it.
The Trust is also investigating instances of the surviving victims’ records being breached – Wayne Birkett, Sharon Miller and Marcin Gawronski.


Emma fears the discoveries are only the beginning, claiming unauthorised access is “rife” across public services and these cases are just “the tip of the iceberg”.
When a tragedy hits the headlines, nowadays staff will be snooping in the victims’ medical records within days to sate “morbid curiosity” before they are even buried, she says.
And the snooping extends far beyond the NHS to “everywhere you could possibly imagine”.
Emma told The Sun: “In our case it was every agency. It was , court staff, NHS. Everywhere down to surgeries.“
“They accessed data on the victims, now on me and Dave too. It’s everywhere you can possibly imagine.”
Court and prison staff at different agencies were found to have accessed evidence on the Nottingham tragedy “inappropriately and without authorisation”.
Three council anti-social behaviour officers too accessed information about the attack “without a legitimate purpose”.
'Disgusting' breaches rife in NHS
SNOOPING into records is ‘rife’ across the public service agencies, with staff looking at high profile victims’ files just days after they are horrifically killed.
Shockingly, this is happening right under the government’s noses, with authorities having no clue until the victims’ families request an audit themselves.
In some cases that generate significant public interest, the NHS or police force check for breaches themselves. But staff could be snooping through the records of anyone – in the media or not – without anyone being any the wiser.
- Noah Woods
The three-year-old went missing after leaving a play area “through a gap in the fence”, sparking a massive frantic search earlier this year.
He was tragically found dead in a lake days later. Ten NHS staff were removed from active duty after inappropriately accessing his medical records.
- William Chapman
William, 23, was mauled to death by a tiger after jumping into a zoo enclosure in October.
Just days after his death, the Yorkshire Ambulance Service Trust said two of its workers were being investigated for accessing his files without a “legitimate reason”.
- Child attacked by a crocodile
A three-year-old boy was left fighting for his life after being thrown into a crocodile pit in June.
A week later, it emerged that
- Southport
Axel Rudakubana, then 17, killed three young girls and tried to kill ten others at a themed dance class in 2024.
A hospital trust admitted that nearly 50 staff members looked at victims’ medical records without a valid reason.
These included the records of children.
- Oliver McGowan
Oliver, 18, died in 2016 after being given antipsychotic medication his parents had told doctors he couldn’t have.
His parents spoke to The Sun on the 10-year anniversary of his death and said staff have inappropriately accessed his records as recently as March.
- Michaela Hall
Mum-of-two Michaela, 49, with a kitchen knife at her home in Mount Hawke, Cornwall.
She was killed by her abusive boyfriend, who had been released from just two weeks before in 2021.
Her family recently received a shocking letter informing them that staff viewed her medical records without reason or permission.
In yet another failure, a second letter from the Royal Cornwall Hospitals NHS Trust then said staff had accessed her sons’ and her ex- partner’s medical records also.
- Princess Kate
In March 2024, three London Clinic workers were under investigation over claims they tried to access Princess Kate’s medical records.
The trio all work at the where the had abdominal surgery, and where is being treated for cancer .
- Minnie Merriman
Nine-year-old Minnie died at Dundee’s Ninewells Hospital in August after being found in a town where she was camping with her family.
The youngster’s dad Christopher Rice, 35, has been charged with her murder.
NHS Tayside is investigating claims that staff working at the hospital accessed the child’s medical records without permission or clinical need.
- Rebecca Matthews
Rebecca’s medical records were accessed after she began campaigning for better maternity care.
She is the lead campaigner at Families Failed by University Hospitals and says the snooping in her files is more “targeted”.
Rebecca had to chase for months after requesting all of the information the NHS Trust held on her, and finally got it in May.
A recent study found that over 2000 NHS staff have been sanctioned for inappropriately looking at patient records in the past five years.
The Information Commissioner’s Office has also written to health leaders across the country, urging them to tackle unauthorised access.
Between January and October this year, it received and assessed more than 300 reports relating to “unauthorised access in the health sector.”
Families calling for systematic change have been forced to dig up the true extent of breaches for themselves.
Emma is one of 44 people to sign an open letter to , and the NHS Chief Executive Officer.
They’re asking for “decisive and immediate action” to prevent further breaches and improve safeguarding.
It also raises concerns about children caught up in the Southport tragedy, whose records were allegedly accessed by people with no involvement in their care.


The letter says: “Strangers probed their most sensitive and personal information in a flagrant abuse of power.”
For Emma, the repeated discoveries have meant her family have been forced to keep fighting for answers long after Barnaby’s murder.
She added: “We’ve not been told about any of the breaches in good faith. It is always on us to find it out. That just adds to the trauma. It’s relentless. There are winds of change but it’s always on the victims to force the government to listen.
- Have staff illegally snooped in your medical files? Email emily.davies@thesun.co.uk
“Only by making staff aware of the consequences – of losing their job or going to prison – will it stop. It’s the culture. It’s appalling.”
An inquiry into the Nottingham tragedy revealed how signs that killer Calocane was a danger to the public were ignored by two police forces, mental health workers and university staff from as early as May 2020.
In her speech, Judge Deborah Taylor remarked how the families have “climbed mountains only to find they have reached false summit after false summit” in reference to their quest for answers.
FOI reveals 10 worst NHS Trusts for breaches
University Hospitals of Morecambe Bay: 242
West Suffolk: 213
Northumbria Healthcare: 195
Wrightington, Wigan & Leigh: 194
East of England Ambulance Service: 182
The Queen Elizabeth Hospital, King’s Lynn: 107
Milton Keynes University Hospital: 94
East Sussex Healthcare: 91
Doncaster & Bassetlaw Teaching Hospitals: 90
East Suffolk & North Essex: 64
Dr Manjeet Shehmar, Medical Director at NUH, said: “There is simply no excuse for accessing the records of a patient without a legitimate reason and I hope this sends a really clear message – we will investigate and we will take action.
“To lose a loved one in the way that the families of Ian, Grace and Barnaby have is heartbreaking enough. I am so sorry that they have had this further compounded by the actions of these staff members.
“We will continue to investigate inappropriate access to these records and take action as and where necessary.
“Alongside this, we are doing all we can to educate our staff on appropriate access and how to keep the records of our patients safe. We are also introducing a new system which acts to detect possible data breaches.
“While the actions of these staff members are disappointing, we know that this represents a small number of our wider workforce.
“We know staff across the Trust are listening, learning and doing what they can to ensure that only lawful and justified access takes place in our hospitals.”
The Trust is setting up a new system to continually monitor access, identify suspicious behaviour, and generate alerts, audits and reports.


Sickeningly, cops handling the harrowing case sent vile messages saying the victims were “properly butchered”.
of the victims’ injuries in “crude and distasteful” messages – and the families weren’t even told until a year later.
PC Matthew Gell was given a final warning, while another officer received “management intervention”.
Emma, 53, told The Sun that one cop viewed 12 hours of bodyworn footage and resigned before he could be sacked. She is currently pursuing legal action against him.
“You put your trust in these agencies to protect and serve. They failed us in the Calocane case and they’ve failed us again and again,” Emma said.
“The victims are not even buried and it’s accessed straight away. It’s not for welfare purposes, it’s to sate curiosity.”
She is urging anyone who worries that someone could have gone snooping in their files to request the information.
“We don’t know how bad it is. They throw all this red tape at us and hope that if they push back enough we will give up and go away, but we will fight for as long as it takes.
“It’s a drop in the ocean. It’s so disgusting. But we have solidarity because there are so many of us.”
The Sun has reached out to Nottinghamshire Police for further comment.