Did Alan Carr Just Reveal He's a Traitor? Fans of Celebrity Traitors Think They Caught a Clue During the Tense Roundtable!

Published on October 30, 2025 at 10:59 AM
Estimated Read Time:

CELEBRITY Traitors fans are convinced Alan Carr has let slip his true Traitor identity after they spotted one key clue.

It came after his Traitor team-mate – with the chat show host blasting the cast as “idiots” prior to his exit.

Alan Carr wearing glasses and a floral shirt.Celebrity Traitors fans reckon Alan Carr has given the game away with regard to his Traitor statusCredit: BBC Celebrities Jonathon Ross, Kat Burns, Alan Carr, and Stephen Fry sitting around a large compass-themed table.It comes after a nail-biting round table aired on the BBC One showCredit: BBC Alan Carr wearing glasses and a black jacket with a red and white sequined snake design.Fans suspected the comedian, 49, changed demeanour when he was the subject of accusationsCredit: BBC

Both , 49, and their fellow deceptive buddy, singer , 25, betrayed the 64-­year-old TV favourite to make him the first Traitor caught on the show for the first-ever season.

Yet despite going under the radar at Ardross Castle – even choosing to murder his former BFF Paloma Faith in the process – fans now reckon the comedian has been sussed out.

It came after a nail-biting round table, which saw him switch his funnyman persona completely to that of being “angry” when he was accused of being a Traitor.

Fans said their suspicions were again alerted after Alan’s “serious” demeanour when asked to share his thoughts by ever-suspicious rugby player , 35.

After the scenes aired, one show fan posted online: “I’m surprised the Faithfuls haven’t picked up Alan’s angry reaction whenever someone points to him as a possible traitor… he switches from jovial camp Alan, to very serious.

“Will Alan’s response to Joe asking him to say something at the roundtable finally draw attention to Alan as a traitor?”

Another put: “I think that too, it’s so defensive, he’d have been far better just playing along but it’s clear he panics under pressure.

“Ironically, his panic is the only reason he’s made it this far is because they’ve all been hoodwinking by the Paloma murder, which was an act of pure panic/opportunity and nobody thought to think of the counterfactual, ‘who is the only person who could murder Paloma in plain sight?'”

A third put: “I think (so far) Alan’s panicked reaction to Joe saying he couldn’t be murdered has been the biggest giveaway. It wasn’t the reaction of a faithful at all.”

One then mused: “I think the fact the edit keeps showing them bringing it up means it’ll ultimately be Alan’s undoing, whether tonight or next week.”

Meanwhile, as the episode unfolded, fans suggested Alan was locked in with a feud with , 58.

It came after dig.

Meanwhile, Alan has the backing of former winner Harry Clark – who reckons

JONATHAN’S EXIT

Claudia Winkleman's career so far

Holiday (1992–1996): Claudia started her TV career as a travel show presenter, delivering segments from exotic locations.

Strictly Come Dancing: It Takes Two (2004–2010): Although she worked on a few shows between Holiday and Strictly, Claudia really came into her own as a presenter on this spin-off, where she could be seen offering behind-the-scenes gossip and interviewing contestants. She hosted from its inception until took over from her in 2011.

(2014–present): After the BBC show due to health concerns, Claudia joined as a co-host of the main show. This is one of the jobs Claudia is best known for.

Film 2010 (2010–2016): Claudia succeeded as the host of the BBC’s flagship film review show in 2010. She was praised by The Guardian for being a “passionate and engaging advocate of cinema” in this role.

The Great British Sewing Bee (2013–2016): Claudia brought her wit to the crafting competition for three years.

The Traitors (2022-present): Claudia’s dark hair and resting mysterious face have become synonymous with this hit reality show. Despite her after the first series in case future seasons flopped, BBC bosses were determined to keep her on, so it seems unlikely she’ll stop heading up the show anytime soon.

Jonathan spoke candidly to us after he was given the boot.

Chatting to The Sun following his show exit he said he hoped Cat and Alan “will stick together and they will romp off to victory”.

for a number of episodes from his co-stars, but his luck finally ran out in the third-from-last episode.

Alan had hinted at the betrayal before the Round Table began, saying: “Jonathan’s name is on everyone’s lips.”

And Cat wasted no time once the meeting began, saying: “I just wanted to be honest in that I’m a bit suspicious of you, Jonathan.”

Alan backed her up, falsely suggesting he was in cahoots with former England rugby player Joe — a Faithful.

It was Joe who believed that Jonathan would have been chosen as a Traitor because he was a showbiz heavyweight “big dog”.

The comments convinced others as Jonathan was banished — revealing his status in comical fashion.

Smirking, he announced: “I am now and I have been all through the game completely faithful  . . .  to the Traitors!”

SPEAKING OUT

Jonathan later revealed he has no hard feelings over the betrayal.

He said: “They got me! But I’m kind of relieved and I’m glad that Alan went for me as well.”

He hopes the pair go on to triumph, but suspects only Cat might survive to the end.

He said: “In my dream scenario, it would be Cat and Alan. I don’t think Alan’s going to survive, but I think Cat will make it to the end.

Jonathan Ross, Alan Carr, and Cat Burns in cloaks, gathered around a large basin in a dimly lit room with lanterns.It came as his fellow traitor Jonathan Ross was evictedCredit: BBC Alan Carr in a cream and beige striped cardigan, looking sideways.Fans said Alan’s reaction will be his ‘undoing’Credit: BBC A man with a mohawk, beard, and purple hoodie looks to his left.It came after he was grilled by Joe Marler on sharing his viewsCredit: BBC

Prev Article Should Rachel Reeves Face Scrutiny for Renting Her Home Without a License? Cast Your Vote!
Next Article NPFL: Bosso Speaks Out on Barau FC’s Rocky Start to the 2025/26 Season

Related to this topic:

GDPR Compliance

We use cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. By continuing to use our site, you accept our use of cookies, Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service.

Search

Newsletter image

Subscribe to the Newsletter

Join 10k+ people to get notified about new posts, news and tips.

Do not worry we don't spam!