Should Bruno Fernandes be taken off penalties? Stats show Man Utd have BETTER taker waiting if Amorim makes change

Published on August 25, 2025 at 07:07 PM
Estimated Read Time:

'Upset' Bruno Fernandes claims he was 'triggered' by referee before horror Man Utd penalty miss

AMID all the chaos at Manchester United, their choice of penalty taker has been a calming and reassuring constant.

Bruno Fernandes has one of the best spot-kick records in the Premier League, regularly digging the Red Devils out of trouble from 12 yards since he arrived at Old Trafford in January 2020.

Bruno Fernandes of Manchester United reacts during a soccer match.
Bruno Fernandes missed a crucial penalty against Fulham on Sunday
Bruno Fernandes of Manchester United missing a penalty kick.
Fernandes blazed his effort over the bar
Manchester United manager Ruben Amorim looking distressed.
Ruben Amorim could have reason to change his spot-kick taker

Yet following his woeful miss at Fulham on Sunday that cost United three points, is it time for boss Ruben Amorim to consider the unthinkable and shake things up, especially with new-boys Bryan Mbeumo and Matheus Cunha waiting in the wings?

Portuguese midfielder Fernandes has now scored 22 of his 27 penalties for United in the Prem – an 81.5 per cent success rate. Not too shabby.

He is in good company. Liverpool’s Mo Salah has an 85 per cent success rate with 34 goals in 40 attempts. Manchester City’s Erling Haaland has an 89 per cent success rate with 17 from 19.

In the United history books, Fernandes has bettered Wayne Rooney [71 per cent with 20 from 28], while Ruud van Nistelrooy scored 18 from 22 for an 82 per cent success rate.

And in his total career to date, including his spells at Udinese and Sporting Lisbon , Fernandes has scored 35 penalties from 41 attempts for an overall 85.4 per cent.

But that horrific miss at Craven Cottage – blazed over the bar after admitting he was “triggered” by ref Chris Kavanagh bumping into him during his run-up – leaves a bitter taste.

That’s because standing on the pitch at the time were two takers with just as impressive stats from the penalty spot.

Mbeumo – signed from Brentford this summer for £71m – netted 10 of his 11 attempts for the Bees for a success rate of 90.9 per cent.

Matheus Cunha and another Manchester United player warming up.
Matheus Cunha and Bryan Mbeumo both boast impressive records from 12 yards

CASINO SPECIAL – BEST CASINO BONUSES FROM £10 DEPOSITS

Another new arrival in Cunha – signed for £62.5m – has a smaller case study, scoring his only Prem penalty for Wolves while two from three at Hertha Berlin, giving him a career success rate of 75 per cent.

Over £130m of attacking talent surely cannot go to waste in the biggest of moments, particularly where penalties are concerned.

Man Utd 'gave' the game to Fulham says Ruben Amorim after 1-1 draw

There will be no panic from Amorim, seeing as Fernandes’ last Prem miss from the spot was TWENTY months ago in December 2023.

The United skipper will no doubt take on the responsibility again when the next opportunity arrives, but perhaps easing the burden from his shoulders and sharing it around could be good for him in the long run.

And for the first time in a long time, United have options in that regard – ones who know what it takes to convert under pressure.

Graphic comparing penalty success rates for Bruno Fernandes, Bryan Mbeumo, and Matheus Cunha.

Prev Article Cruel trolls say I need to see an ‘exorcist’ due to my rare condition – it’s so bad I struggle to leave the house
Next Article Brazil welcomes Tinubu with full military honours

Related to this topic:

GDPR Compliance

We use cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. By continuing to use our site, you accept our use of cookies, Privacy Policy, and Terms of Service.

Search

Newsletter image

Subscribe to the Newsletter

Join 10k+ people to get notified about new posts, news and tips.

Do not worry we don't spam!