A MARRIED school football coach has been jailed after allegedly sending sexual snaps to a 16-year-old student and having sex with him.
Mary “Hanna” Mattingly, 31, was arrested Monday in Kentucky following claims she had “sexual contact” with the teen.
Mary Mattingly, a school football coach, was arrested for alleged sexual contact with a studentCredit: Facebook/Keith Mattingly
The 31-year-old’s booking photo at Nelson County Correctional CenterCredit: Nelson County Correctional Center
The substitute teacher pictured with her husband KeithCredit: Facebook/Keith Mattingly
The coach was also a substitute teacher at Bardstown High School and worked with the school’s girls’ teams.
She allegedly sent the student “partially nude” photos and exchanged messages with him, according to police.
The shocking case came to light after an anonymous letter was sent to the school, reportedly accusing Mattingly of “inappropriate contact” with a student.
School chiefs moved quickly, with superintendent Ryan Clark saying that “Bardstown City Schools immediately initiated an investigation, removed the individual from her job duties, placed her on administrative leave and alerted the authorities.”
Cops allege Mattingly, “being in the position of special trust as a school teacher at Bardstown High School, engaged in sexual contact with a high school student.”
She was arrested by Bardstown Police and charged with first-degree sexual abuse and procuring or promoting abuse of a minor by electronic means.
Mattingly is being held on a $20,000 bond at the Nelson County Jail and is due in court next Tuesday.
The scandal has rocked Bardstown, a small city of about 13,500 people roughly 40 miles south of Louisville.
The investigation is ongoing.
It comes as a after allegedly using her classroom and car to carry out sexual encounters with a student.
Ashley Fisler, 36, was arrested on Thursday after a former pupil – now an adult – went to police with the disturbing claims.
The accuser told officers the alleged abuse happened in 2021 while they were attending Orchard Valley Middle School in Washington Township, New Jersey.
An anonymous letter to the school initiated an investigation and led to Mattingly’s arrestCredit: Facebook/Alisha Maupin
Mattingly smiling with her husband Keith and their two children in happier timesCredit: Facebook/Keith Mattingly
Fisler was working there as a social studies teacher at the time.
Authorities claim there were multiple incidents, said to have taken place both inside the classroom and in Fisler’s car.
Officials added that text messages between the pair backed up the “unlawful sexual nature of their relationship.”
Fisler is understood to have taught social studies in the Washington Township School District from 2014 until June 2023.
She is no longer employed as a teacher.
Meanwhile, a – and kept messaging him even after being hit with serious charges.
Tera Johnson-Swartz, 45, from Colorado, was sentenced to 14 years in prison – first over her relationship with a 16-year-old student, and then for breaching a court order by continuing to contact him.
The former STEM School Highlands Ranch teacher, near Denver, reportedly began texting the teen and sharing music playlists in 2024, when he was just 16.
Court documents claim she gave him cigarettes and allowed him to use her marijuana vape pen before the relationship allegedly turned sexual.
At the same time, Johnson-Swartz had been named one of seven finalists for Colorado’s Teacher of the Year award.



