CHANNEL 5 made a bold creative decision when making their new NFL sport show – and it has not gone down well.
The broadcaster secured rights to show the in the UK, but rather than feature the typical style of analysis and punditry, they opted for a new game show-esque format.
Dermot O’Leary hosted the new game show inspired format for NFL broadcasts
He even got stuck in himself riding the Bucking Bronco in the studio
The site describes the show, ‘NFL: Big Game Night’, as a “completely new way to enjoy watching the greatest show on turf.
“Each week,” the brief continues, “Dermot will be joined by Sam [Quek] and Osi [Umenyiora] in a purpose-built studio for an entertainment format that runs alongside the big NFL Game of the Week at 6pm on 5.
“Whenever the NFL game stops in the US, 5 will keep going with the fun and games – in the form of the unique ‘game within a game’.
“Two teams of friends and family in the UK will battle for prizes in a series of games that are fast, furious and fun.”
The show clearly makes a mammoth effort to innovate sports broadcasting, in this case with mechanical bulls and family feud-style game show intervals.
It is safe to say, however, that NFL fans in the UK were not at all pleased by the ridiculous nature of the broadcast when it debuted on Sunday.
If you aren't watching Channel 5's NFL coverage you're missing out on Partridge levels of cringe. Every time the play stops it cuts to a studio where Dermot O'Leary hosts the cheapest American football-themed game show you've ever seen. Bucking broncos and everything pic.twitter.com/LpReLIFVQx
— Chris Scullion (@scully1888) September 7, 2025
One X user responded to a picture of host riding a bucking bronco.
They said: “So Channel 5 Sport are actually doing this during the game. This is embarrassing and UK NFL fans deserve better than this.
“Whoever signed off on this format needs to be fired.”
Another user lamented the missed opportunity to grow the audience of the NFL in the UK with insightful coverage.
They said: “Channel 5 had a real chance to help educate people and offer analysis to new NFL fans.
“Instead they are playing games and interviewing . Disappointing.”
The show is set to be Channel 5’s offering for NFL game nights going forward, meaning it is worth keeping an eye out to see if the broadcaster makes any sweeping changes to the format in response to the backlash.
It is not the only bold new format for NFL coverage this season.
YouTube have also debuted their where fans can watch games along with their favourite content creators on the site.
