A FLORIDA man allegedly mailed a peanut butter-smeared greeting card to his ex-wife’s friend despite knowing she had a potentially deadly allergy to peanuts.
Joseph Gerard Cancellare Jr., 68, is accused of deliberately targeting the woman in a bizarre revenge plot after blaming her for the breakdown of his marriage.



The shocking stunt allegedly left the victim covered in hives and suffering a tingling sensation for nearly six hours after she opened the mysterious envelope.
Cancellare was arrested on Friday, November 13, more than a year after the alleged attack, according to the Plantation Police Department.
The woman had returned home from work on August 14, 2025, when she spotted a greasy blue envelope with unfamiliar handwriting in her driveway, CBS News reported.
Inside was a greeting card smeared with a mysterious brown substance that she immediately recognized as peanut butter.
The terrified woman dropped the envelope, called for help and rushed inside to scrub her hands.
She later told investigators that even touching peanuts or inhaling airborne particles could trigger a life-threatening reaction.
Police said the woman developed hives on both arms and experienced tingling for approximately six hours.
Her severe allergy had previously been documented in a 2017 police report, with medical records confirming the seriousness of her condition.
Investigators believe the alleged attack was fueled by Cancellare’s bitter divorce from his wife.
The suspect and victim had known each other for more than 20 years, regularly socializing with their spouses.
But their relationship reportedly soured when the woman allegedly became involved in the couple’s contentious split.
She last spoke to Cancellare in July 2022, when she witnessed the division of property during his divorce, according to an arrest affidavit cited by the New York Post .
Police said Cancellare blamed the woman for his marriage falling apart.
One mutual acquaintance even claimed the 68-year-old had previously expressed a desire to hurt her.
Witnesses also told investigators that Cancellare knew about the woman’s severe allergy, having watched her take special precautions while eating out.
Detectives believe he deliberately exploited that vulnerability in an attempt to cause serious harm.
But the alleged revenge plot began unravelling when investigators discovered a crucial clue hidden in the envelope’s postage stamps.
With help from a US postal inspector, detectives traced two Forever stamps to a self-service kiosk at a post office in Davie, Florida.
The stamps had been purchased on August 8, 2025, using a Visa card registered to Cancellare, police said.
Surveillance images from the kiosk also allegedly captured the suspect buying the stamps.
When shown the photograph, the victim immediately identified Cancellare, with several other acquaintances also recognizing him.
Investigators claimed the 68-year-old had travelled to a post office in another city, worn sunglasses inside and used a fake name and return address in an apparent attempt to hide his identity.
The envelope was processed through a Miami postal facility on August 13, just one day before it reached the woman’s home.
Detectives concluded that Cancellare had intentionally exposed the victim to peanut butter despite knowing it could cause serious injury or death.
According to the affidavit, investigators believe he intended to cause death or serious bodily injury.
Cancellare was arrested at his home on November 13 and taken to hospital for medical clearance before being booked into jail.
He faces charges of aggravated battery with a deadly weapon and culpable negligence exposing another person to harm.
His bond was set at $20,000, according to the New York Post.